Leave a Message

By providing your contact information to Ann Newton Cane, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Ann Newton Cane's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you expressly consent to receive marketing or promotional real estate communication from Ann Newton Cane in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase of any goods or services. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Ann Newton Cane at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe. SMS text messaging is subject to our Terms of Use.

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Explore Our Properties
Soft November light fills an elegant dining room with a walnut table and bay window overlooking a leafy enclosed garden.

What a Piedmont List Price Tells You About the Final Price

November 19, 2026

Two houses on Indian Road closed five days apart in early October. 114 Indian Rd was listed at $2,395,000 and closed on October 2, 2026 at $2,600,000, about 9% over its asking price. 140 Indian Road was listed at $2,495,000 and closed on October 7, 2026 at $4,300,000, which is 72% over. The two asking prices were $100,000 apart. The two sale prices were $1.7 million apart, and the larger house, at 2,959 square feet, is the one that sold for less. Per square foot, 114 Indian Rd closed at $879 and 140 Indian Road at $1,564.

Same street, same month, nearly the same asking price, and the outcomes had little in common. That is typical for Piedmont. Across the 13 months of closings published by the Piedmont Exedra from bridgeMLS data, how far a home sold over its list price depended mostly on two things: where the list price started, and what time of year the home sold. In the lower price bands the list price is where bidding opens. Near the top of the market it is close to the actual price. Last winter, the over-list premium mostly disappeared across every band.

The premium shrinks as the asking price rises

The table groups every Piedmont single-family closing from October 2025 through October 2026 by list price. The figures are our own calculations from the bridgeMLS records the Exedra published. We left out one record with an obvious data-entry error and three rows that were duplicates.

List price band, Oct 2025 to Oct 2026 closings

Closings

Median sale price as % of list

Closed at or below list

Under $2,000,000

67

about 135%

8

$2,000,000 to $4,499,999

68

about 122%

9

$4,500,000 and above

14

about 106%

5

At the median, a home listed under $2 million sold for about a third more than its asking price. Above $4.5 million the median premium was about 6%, and more than a third of those sales closed at or below list. Each step up in list price narrowed the gap.

This has a simple economic explanation. A list price works as a floor only when enough buyers want the house to bid it up. Many more households can compete for a $1.8 million house than for an $8 million one, so a low asking price in the lower band draws a crowd. In the upper band the same tactic has fewer bidders to work on.

Under $2 million, $1,995,000 is a starting point

The most common asking price in Piedmont over these 13 months was exactly $1,995,000. Eleven homes listed at that number closed between October 2025 and October 2026. Their sale prices ran from $2,150,000 at 24 Somerset Rd to $3,250,000 at 55 Fairview Ave., and the median was $2,670,000. Two houses on Kingston Ave carried that same list price and closed two weeks apart in October 2026. 926 Kingston Ave sold at $2,702,000 and 920 Kingston Ave at $2,603,000.

At this level the asking price says roughly which bracket of buyer the seller wants to attract. It does not say what the house will sell for. The largest premiums in the data came from homes listed well below $2 million:

  • 306 Wildwood Ave, listed at $1,598,000, closed at $2,808,000 in May 2026.
  • 340 Jerome Ave, listed at $995,000, closed at $1,725,000 in May 2026.
  • 1120 Warfield Ave, listed at $998,000, closed at $1,655,000 in July 2026.
  • 102 York Dr, listed at $1,692,000, closed at $2,502,000 in September 2026.

The same pattern continued into the middle band. 132 Caperton Ave went from $2,495,000 to $4,200,000 in May 2026, and 66 Manor Dr from $2,800,000 to $4,200,000 in August 2026. All 13 Piedmont closings in October 2026 sold over list, at a median of about 128% of asking and a median sale price of $2.85 million. Those are our calculations from that month's records.

For a buyer, a listing at $1,995,000 should be budgeted as a house that has recently sold for somewhere between about $2.2 million and $3.25 million. The asking price narrows that range very little. Recent closings on the same street, with similar square footage and lot size, narrow it more.

Above $4.5 million, the asking price is close to the price

At the top of the market, the list price usually came close to the outcome. 44 Farragut Ave closed at its $11,750,000 asking price in January 2026. 25 Crocker Ave was listed at $7,750,000 and closed at $7,556,250 in February. 415 Pacific Ave was listed at $5,500,000 and closed at $5,000,000 in June. 26 Sea View Ave, on a lot of almost 120,000 square feet, was listed at $15,000,000 and closed at $12,750,000 in November 2025.

When upper-band homes did sell over list, the margins were mostly modest. 125 Guilford Rd went from $7,775,000 to $8,100,000, 62 Farragut Ave from $7,900,000 to $8,400,000, and 10 Muir Ave from $5,495,000 to $5,758,000.

This band had real exceptions, though, and they matter for anyone shopping in it. 224 Mountain Ave was listed at $5,500,000 and closed at $7,500,000 in April 2026. 333 Hampton Rd went from $4,995,000 to $6,200,000 in February, and 6 Muir Ave from $5,295,000 to $6,350,000 in April. Upper-band homes can still sell well over list, but in this data it happened in a minority of sales, and five of the 14 closed at or below their asking price.

Last winter, the premium mostly disappeared

The season mattered too. Fifteen Piedmont homes closed in December 2025 and January 2026. Eight of the 15 closed at or below list, and the median sale was right at the asking price.

Every price band showed it. 21 Arroyo Ave closed at its $1,900,000 list price, 1361 Oakland Ave at $1,350,000, and 107 Monticello Ave at $1,729,200, all in December 2025. 187 St James Dr was listed at $1,950,000 and closed at $1,575,000. 61 Wildwood Ave was listed at $2,398,000 and closed at $2,250,000. 21 Tyson Cir closed just under its $2,399,000 asking price. 1850 Trestle Glen Rd closed at its $3,000,000 list price in January. Only three Piedmont homes closed in all of January 2026.

Some winter listings still drew strong bids. 235 Sunnyside Ave went from $1,795,000 to $2,635,000, 1150 Oakland Ave from $1,995,000 to $2,801,017, and 64 Sharon Ave from $4,380,000 to $5,896,000, all in December 2025. By February the large premiums were back. 37 Monticello Ave went from $1,795,000 to $2,450,000, and 46 Manor Dr from $1,585,000 to $2,300,000. In March, 15 Mesa Ave went from $2,328,000 to $3,650,000.

Last winter, then, the at-list closings were concentrated in December and January, between an October and a February that both ran well over list. In the lower bands, the gap between a winter closing at list and a spring closing at about 135% of list is the largest single swing in the data.

Reading a Piedmont listing this winter

As this post goes up the week before Thanksgiving, Piedmont is heading into the same stretch of the calendar that produced last winter's at-list closings. Taken together, the three patterns above give a buyer a practical way to read an asking price.

The price band is the first filter. A house listed under $2 million has usually sold for well above its asking price, a house listed above $4.5 million has usually sold close to it, and the middle band has run in between, at about 122% of list at the median.

The calendar adjusts that estimate. Through most of 2026 a $1,995,000 listing implied a sale near $2.67 million, while homes that closed in December 2025 and January 2026 most often closed at or near their asking price. Last winter does not guarantee the same result this year, but those closings belong in any offer plan made between now and January.

Street-level comparisons per square foot finish the picture. The two Indian Road sales show that two houses with similar asking prices can sell at very different prices per square foot. 114 Indian Rd closed at $879 per square foot and 140 Indian Road at $1,564, and the sale price per square foot is what prices a house. On Wildwood Ave, 306 Wildwood closed at $1,603 per square foot in May 2026 and 314 Wildwood at $1,355 in August. For buyers whose budget in the lower band is moving into jumbo financing, our earlier post on jumbo and conforming loans in Piedmont covers how loan size shapes an offer. Our Piedmont neighborhood page covers the city's streets and housing stock.

If you own a home in Piedmont, the same data shows what timing means for you. Last year, homes that closed in December often sold at their asking price, while similar asking prices in spring drew bids far above list, and on a $2 million house that difference ran to hundreds of thousands of dollars. Ann Newton Cane can walk you through the recent Piedmont closings in your band and on your street before you set a number. If you are deciding whether to list this winter or wait for spring, request a Confidential Home Valuation, or read more about Ann's work in Piedmont.

Follow Us On Instagram